Trending Now
Analysis: EU’s new sanctions rock diesel market, price hikes expected
EU defense chief warns of ‘most dangerous moment’ – coordinated Russian-Chinese...
Deputy AG seeks Ghislaine Maxwell meeting in Epstein investigation
Trump pulls US out of UN agency over its backing of...
US to exit UNESCO again, citing anti-Israel bias and “woke” agenda
Goldman Sachs warns of slower US growth amid rising tariff pressures
China denies wrongdoing in preventing dozens of Americans from leaving under...
Salvadoran president responds to Hunter Biden’s invasion threat: What is he...
Powell’s speech today didn’t give Wall Street what it was hoping...
Trump admin courts Amazon, defence giants for Golden Dome amid Musk...
Analysis: EU’s new sanctions rock diesel market, price hikes expected
EU defense chief warns of ‘most dangerous moment’ – coordinated Russian-Chinese...
Deputy AG seeks Ghislaine Maxwell meeting in Epstein investigation
Trump pulls US out of UN agency over its backing of...
US to exit UNESCO again, citing anti-Israel bias and “woke” agenda
Goldman Sachs warns of slower US growth amid rising tariff pressures
China denies wrongdoing in preventing dozens of Americans from leaving under...
Salvadoran president responds to Hunter Biden’s invasion threat: What is he...
Powell’s speech today didn’t give Wall Street what it was hoping...
Trump admin courts Amazon, defence giants for Golden Dome amid Musk...
Insider Dealing News
  • Stock
  • Investing
  • Politics
  • World News
  • Editor’s Pick
World News

American Bar Association blasts Bondi’s decision to block it from judicial nominations: ‘Deeply disturbing’

by June 11, 2025
written by June 11, 2025

The American Bar Association asked the Department of Justice on Tuesday to reconsider its historic decision to shut the organization out of the judicial nomination process and insisted it rates potential judges fairly.

ABA President William Bay wrote to Attorney General Pam Bondi that he was ‘surprised and disappointed’ by her decision, which Bondi revealed in a letter two weeks ago.

‘It is deeply disturbing that the Justice Department has decided to restrict access to judicial nominees without justification or basis,’ Bay wrote.

Bondi accused the ABA, which comprises hundreds of thousands of lawyers and other legal professionals, of favoring Democratic administrations’ nominees and refusing to ‘fix the bias in its ratings.’

The ABA has for seven decades been involved in rating presidents’ nominees to serve as judges in the district and appellate courts and the Supreme Court.

An ABA committee rates potential judges as ‘well qualified,’ ‘qualified’ or ‘not qualified’ based on their experience level, legal writings, and dozens of interviews with the candidates’ colleagues and peers.

Bay noted the ABA rated all three of President Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominees as ‘well qualified’ and that it has given ‘well qualified’ or ‘qualified’ ratings to at least 97% of rated nominees for the last two decades.

The ABA has also received nonpublic information about nominees, including their bar records, through DOJ waivers. Bondi said the department will no longer provide those.

Bay’s remarks were the latest development in a protracted legal fight that Trump and Republicans have waged against the ABA and big law over allegations they are plagued by bias. The ABA has on occasion promoted liberal initiatives, including abortion access, diversity, equity, and inclusion, and the LGBTQ agenda. Bay said the rating committee is walled off from the rest of the organization.

‘The Standing Committee’s work is insulated from all other activities of the ABA to ensure its independence and impartiality,’ Bay wrote.

Presidents nominate federal judges, and the Senate votes on them. The judges, once confirmed, serve lifetime appointments.

Presidents and the Senate have for decades included the ABA in the nomination process, but Trump and President George W. Bush declined to give the ABA a first look at potential nominees before announcing them.

Former President Joe Biden continued Trump’s practice but clarified that he valued the ABA’s ratings and only gave it post-nomination access to nominee information to save time.

A DOJ spokesman said in response to Bay’s letter: ‘It’s clear that the American Bar Association has lost its way and no longer treats all nominees in a fair and impartial manner.’

Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, who leads the Senate panel tasked with vetting potential judges, said in response to Bondi’s decision that it was ‘hardly surprising’ and that the legal organization has ‘consistently taken partisan stances on political issues.’ Grassley noted the ABA could still weigh in on nominees independently of the administration.

‘The Judiciary Committee will still accept letters from the ABA, the same as we do for all outside organizations, but it doesn’t make sense for this administration to be giving favored access to an organization that’s consistently shown political bias,’ Grassley said.

Grassley’s Democratic counterpart, Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois, said in a statement online that the ABA’s ratings process was objective.

‘The Trump Administration is clearly just trying to cover for unqualified and extreme nominees,’ Durbin said.

Among those once rated as ‘not qualified’ by the ABA was DOJ chief of staff Chad Mizelle’s wife, Kathryn Kimball Mizelle, who serves as a federal judge in Florida. The rating was due to her lack of experience, as the ABA’s criteria for federal judges includes 12 years of experience practicing law.

The ABA had mixed reviews for Justice Clarence Thomas in 1991, ultimately giving him its mid-level ‘qualified’ rating.

This post appeared first on FOX NEWS
0 comment
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

previous post
Rare minerals, student visas, and tariffs: the fine print of the US-China deal
next post
Taiwan envoy urges congressional action, warns of rising China threat after meeting lawmakers

Related Posts

Trump blasts Massie as ‘the worst Republican Congressman’...

July 22, 2025

Federal judge blocks Trump administration from defunding some...

July 22, 2025

‘All the options’: GOP eyes cutting August recess...

July 21, 2025

Obama-era officials mum on allegations of ‘manufactured’ intelligence...

July 21, 2025

Hunter Biden special counsel got ‘one resume’ from...

July 21, 2025

China denies wrongdoing in preventing dozens of Americans...

July 22, 2025

Salvadoran president responds to Hunter Biden’s invasion threat:...

July 22, 2025

EU defense chief warns of ‘most dangerous moment’...

July 22, 2025

Deputy AG seeks Ghislaine Maxwell meeting in Epstein...

July 22, 2025

Trump pulls US out of UN agency over...

July 22, 2025

Trump blasts Massie as ‘the worst Republican Congressman’...

July 22, 2025

Federal judge blocks Trump administration from defunding some...

July 22, 2025

‘All the options’: GOP eyes cutting August recess...

July 21, 2025

Obama-era officials mum on allegations of ‘manufactured’ intelligence...

July 21, 2025

Hunter Biden special counsel got ‘one resume’ from...

July 21, 2025

China denies wrongdoing in preventing dozens of Americans...

July 22, 2025

Salvadoran president responds to Hunter Biden’s invasion threat:...

July 22, 2025

EU defense chief warns of ‘most dangerous moment’...

July 22, 2025

Deputy AG seeks Ghislaine Maxwell meeting in Epstein...

July 22, 2025

Trump pulls US out of UN agency over...

July 22, 2025







    Fill Out & Get More Relevant News





    Stay ahead of the market and unlock exclusive trading insights & timely news. We value your privacy - your information is secure, and you can unsubscribe anytime. Gain an edge with hand-picked trading opportunities, stay informed with market-moving updates, and learn from expert tips & strategies.
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2024 InsiderDealingNews.com All Rights Reserved.

    Insider Dealing News
    • Stock
    • Investing
    • Politics
    • World News
    • Editor’s Pick